Both articles provide valid points for and against illegal immigration. However, I do not know if I can fully agree with either side, as I disagree with some of the points strongly. For example, Michael Scott writes in his article, “America Must Take Stronger Measures to Halt Illegal Immigration,” about the destruction to personal property and safety hazards that come with the immigrants across the border. He points to the filth that is left on people’s property as the immigrants move through, and the livestock and pets that are poisoned or have their throats slit by the immigrant guides. But throughout the article, Scott fails to realize a very critical point; these immigrants are human beings. They are not simply a plague that pushes itself through the border and into the American economy. They are people who are, for the most part, looking for a better life that they were promised they would find in the United States. And in this aspect, Richard Rayner succeeds with his article, “Illegal Immigration Does Not Threaten America.” He points out the struggles of illegal immigrants who, unlike the popular view point says, are not actually receiving any support from the government, and live their lives in utter poverty in order to get by. However, neither article provides a real solution to the problem that America sees with illegal immigration.
The solution, to me, is quite simple, however. I think that what needs to be done is the process to become a citizen needs to be simplified. There need to be stations at critical locations along the border to help immigrants who want to be legal to understand what is needed to become a citizen. A quick Google search brings up the website that explains the whole process, and at first glance it looks very straightforward. After a minute, however, I realized that there are a few problems with the system. The first problem is that immigrants do not have access to this information if they do not have a computer. Who knows how to apply for citizenship other than on the internet? Who would be able to give this information out? How do people find the people who have this information if they are not making themselves known? The second problem is that, as with all processes that are tied to the government, it is not terribly simple to understand. Even if somehow the immigrants gained access to a computer, if the website is too hard to understand, it’s as if they didn’t have the resource to begin with. Not every immigrant has someone to ask for help with this, who is on hand whenever they need them. Even then, after understanding the process, they would find out that they need to fill out forms for a green card, then wait five years before having any hope of becoming a citizen. But I’m sure many immigrants would have no problem doing this, as long as the information is provided. As a bonus, this system would provide more jobs for the American people by placing them at the border to help immigrants through properly, and in positions to help them understand the process.
No comments:
Post a Comment