Journal 8


            The three articles, “Black Friday: Consumerism Minus Civilization” by Andrew Leonard, “Friday’s Deals May Not Be the Best” by Stephanie Clifford, and “For Some Black Friday First-Timers, Not a Night of Conversion” by Stephanie Clifford and Christopher Maag, all address the issues that can be found when looking at Black Friday as a cultural phenomenon.  Each article approaches the topic with different main ideas, but each reaches the same basic conclusion about Black Friday; that the idea of its deals and discounts cause people to act crazily.
            In Leonard’s article, he approaches the topic of Black Friday through the human morality aspect, and focusing mainly on the issue of Black Friday advertising.  He argues that the ideals present in the minds of the shoppers on Black Friday go against what we, as humans, find morally right.  However, he writes, the craziness of the shoppers, like the Crazy Target Lady from Target’s Black Friday commercial, is “a culturally approved lunacy.”  Not only is this characteristic of the event itself, but Leonard says that the individual stores use their advertisements to foster this immoral behavior, the insanity that goes on inside the stores and even before hand as people prepare to go shopping early in the morning or late at night.
            In the first New York Times article by Stephanie Clifford, “Friday’s Deals May Not Be the Best”, Clifford writes that, despite the hype and advertising done by businesses, Black Friday does not even actually help the consumers.  Although the advertisements make it seem like these Black Friday deals are the very best and lowest prices, this, in reality, is not the case.  Black Friday is the day when retailers, historically, see an increase in sales due to the day’s proximity to Christmas.  Because people see this time as the best time to start holiday shopping, retailers react by hosting sales to get people to come to their stores.  However, as Clifford points out, the reality is that if consumers were to wait just a few more weeks, they would find even better sales and discounts because stores need to sell their inventory quickly, or risk never selling it at all. 
            The next article, “For Some Black Friday First-Timers, Not a Night of Conversion” by Stephanie Clifford and Christopher Maag, focuses on the consumer, especially first-time Black Friday shoppers.  The shoppers learn the realities of Black Friday, people being trampled and fighting over products.  Some people don’t even have anything to show for their trip.  The article shows that that year’s Black Friday brought in around two thousand more people to Macy’s Herald Square than the year before.  The article goes on to show why this was the case.  Because people found themselves out of work or with a much decreased income, they figured that their only hope was to brave the crowds on Black Friday in order to catch the much needed sales and discounts. 

No comments:

Post a Comment