Journal 5

            In her essay, Berry makes the argument that fashion advertisements have recently begun to allow the consumer to be an “individual,” unlike previous fashion and health and beauty advertisements that seemingly forced the viewer to want to conform to a societal definition of “beautiful.”  Her argument is based on two shoe ads depicting young women in outfits showing their originality.  Although the two women shown in the advertisements show their inarguable uniqueness, Berry’s argument is flawed.  The companies are not showing how the individual can be unique through the individuality of their models, but rather they are showing how their product stands apart from the rest. 
            There is one rather important reason that can be argued for the company, Clarks, to use a “band geek” type of style to promote their product.  This reason that comes to mind requires some knowledge of Clarks’ shoes and what being in a high school or college level band, which the model seemingly is in, entails.  Clarks’ shoes are known for their comfort and support, especially when the wearer has to be on his or her feet for long period of time.  In a marching band, the members are required to be on their feet for what can be hours, especially during practice.  So Clarks’ shoes would be a great choice for a young woman who is in a band and is looking for a pair of shoes that are good for her feet and are attractive as well.  With this approach, it is seen that the ad is not showing how the consumer can be an individual, but rather how those with individual hobbies and passions can continue to do what they love without sacrificing their fashion sense.  This particular advertisement is obviously reaching out to this particular group of consumers. 
            The second ad shows an entirely different aspect of advertising that has next to nothing to do with individuality.  This ad shows the product in a setting that is out of the ordinary and very attention grabbing.  It shows a woman in a very luxurious room and dress, wearing red snow boots.  The boots do not match the rest of the picture, and so that is what the viewers’ eyes are drawn to, effectively catching the attention of potential consumers. 
            A company’s main objective is to get the consumer to buy their product.  Fashion companies will often do this through visual advertisements, which makes sense because a consumer is likely to buy something that is visually appealing to them.  Although a company may use the want of the consumer to conform to society, the company does not, however, necessarily have the need or want to get the consumer to conform to a certain societal norm, and therefore would have no reason to do the opposite and foster individual creativity.  The point of these two advertisements was to either appeal to an ideal that is already present in the minds of the company’s target consumer or to catch the attention of the consumer with an outlandish yet visually appealing image.  Neither of the advertisements actually stray from the standard set by advertisements of showing attractive young women, and therefore are not much different from previous ads that have the same object of their pictures.  These advertisements are not allowing the viewer to be an individual, they are simply doing their jobs as ads. 

No comments:

Post a Comment