Journal 6

            In the poem, “When I Was One-and-Twenty,” by A.E. Housman, the poet addresses the theme of lost, unrequited, or forsaken love.  In the first stanza, the speaker of the poem is approached by a “wise man,” or probably a member of the generation before him, as many young people, and the speaker, realize too late are people to be listened to and their advice is to be heeded.  The wise man warns the speaker that he should be careful when it comes to matters of love.  He is told that the heart is not like money, and that if it is given away prematurely, it will cause the giver pain and sorrow.  Nevertheless, the speaker of the poem, being young and free-spirited, naturally disregards the advice, feeling, as many young people do, that his youth should be spent freely, and that all his assets, his heart included, should be given away generously because he has so much to give. 
            In the second stanza, the speaker of the poem is warned again of the dangers of giving away his love.  The reader can assume, through the fact that this is something everyone is advised on and is rarely obeyed, that he is warned many, many times by different people.  He continues to ignore the warnings, however, and pays the price for his foolishness.  By the end of the poem, the speaker realizes how true the wise man’s words were, and he mourns his lost love.  The speaker then becomes the wise man to all the readers of his poem. 
            The theme of lost love in this poem is very different from that of other poems, like “Anabel Lee,” by Edgar Allan Poe, for example.  In Poe’s poem, the love was not given away, but shared.  It was the actual object of his affection that was lost due to premature death, rather than the action, as in “When I Was One and Twenty,” falling on an unwilling object. 
            With some research, one can find that the “lost love” that Housman talks about in his poem is based off his feelings for his college roommate (Poets.org).  His roommate, predictably, did not return his feelings, which depressed Housman.  Because of his foolish actions, Housman went on to fail his exams, and only just managed to pass his classes.  For the rest of his life, he lived in solitude. 

 

Works Cited
"A. E. Housman." Poets.org. Academy of American Poets, n.d. Web. 15 Oct. 2013.

No comments:

Post a Comment