Growing Up in the Eyes of a Father


Many of William Butler Yeats’ poems center in on the topic of childhood and growing up.  In older poems, however, Yeats focused more on the loss of childish innocence as children grew into adulthood.  The themes of these poems were darker, as they ended with corruption.  Yeats’ view on childhood and growing up changed, however, when his child was born.  In “A Prayer for My Daughter,” Yeats addresses this topic through the lens of a father, dreaming of what is to come for his daughter and what he hopes her future will be; his intensity is exemplified through the use of symbolism and allusion. 
In the first two stanzas, Yeats refers to the present and the looming presence of the future.   He refers to the future as a storm, and through this symbolism the reader is able to determine how he, as a father, feels about the world into which his daughter is entering.  He says that his daughter is still “half hid / Under this cradle-hood and coverlid,” (1-2) and so the reader knows that she is still only a baby, and for her father to be worrying so far in advance about her adulthood he must feel that her future will be inundated with problems (Yeats).  In these stanzas, Yeats has the storm winds “scream upon the tower,” (10) as well as “under the arches of the bridge” and “in the elms” (11- 12), all of which are popularly accepted symbols for strength.  Yeats uses these symbols to represent his daughter’s childhood and innocence, whilst the storm winds represent growing up and adulthood. 
In the next two stanzas, Yeats talks about beauty in a deeper, more profound light than simply physical beauty and aesthetics.  He, like most parents, hopes for his daughter to grow to be beautiful.  However, he writes that she should not be so beautiful that she “make[s] a stranger's eye distraught, or hers before a looking-glass” (Yeats, 18).  He means that no matter how beautiful she becomes, that should not become her defining characteristic.  Yeats goes on to explain his point through the use of two allusions, one to Helen of Troy and the other to the Greco-Roman goddess Aphrodite or Venus, both famously beautiful women.  He compares the two, describing how Helen’s beauty, when countered with no other redeeming qualities, was “chosen,” as Yeats says, by men solely for her looks, and this ultimately lead to her downfall.  Aphrodite, on the other hand, was not chosen, but chose a husband through compassion.  Yeats’ does not want his daughter to be “chosen” or fought over like Helen of Troy, as he knows this will only lead to conflict, arrogance, and an unhappy marriage.  He wants her to be strong enough choose and not be chosen, and to win people over herself, rather than be won by someone who is undeserving of her. 
In the fifth and sixth stanzas of the poem, Yeats moves on to the topic of more important characteristics than beauty, saying that she should be a “flourishing hidden tree” (41), with the emphasis on hidden (Yeats).  He says that she should be “chiefly learned” in “courtesy” (33), or manners and charm.  He follows this with the phrase, “Hearts are not had as a gift but hearts are earned” (34), meaning that one cannot expect someone to like him or her without giving a good reason for them to do so.  Yeats writes that his daughter should be outspoken with her thoughts, and should be as free with them as a songbird, Yeats writes linnet, is with its music.  He also writes that he hopes she will never start anything without the want or happiness to do so, and that she will stand her ground “like some green laurel / Rooted in one dear perpetual place” (47-48).
In the beginning of the seventh stanza, Yeats talks about his own mind, and how it is old and its thoughts are basically irrelevant now because they are outdated.  However, he states, there is one idea he has that does not become irrelevant as time goes on, and that is that a mind “choked with hate” (52) causes a person to become bitter and evil (Yeats).  He goes on to say that, if this is not the case with a particular person, then that bitterness will not fall upon the person.  He says this with the phrase, “Assault and battery of the wind / Can never tear the linnet from the leaf” (55-56), which brings back the symbolism of the songbird, his daughter, and the storm, her future. 
The next two stanza addresses personal ideology and actions.  Yeats shows in this stanza that, contrary to what some scholars, such as Tsung-chi Chang, write, he does want his daughter to form her own ideas (Chang).  Chang’s article, “W. B. Yeats, Cultural Nationalism, and Disempowered Women”, addresses the issue that many feminist writers have with Yeats’ and many of his peers, which is that, in focusing closely on the empowerment of the Irish people at that time, they subsequently endorse the disempowerment of women.  Chang points to this poem in particular, addressing the aforementioned stanzas.  Her argument is flawed, however, because she does not correctly analyze these lines.  What Yeats is saying is that she should not voice her opinions just for the sake of being heard.  “So let her think opinions are accursed” (58) does not refer to personal opinions, but instead it refers to the kind of boastful or pushy attitude that Yeats has found in some very intellectual and opinionated people (Yeats).  Although Yeats was not necessarily writing a poem with feminist themes, his point was not to disempower women, especially not in this poem and these lines. 
In the final stanzas of the poem, Yeats finishes by stating that, as long as the things he wishes for his daughter come true, she has the chance to “be happy still” (72), even if the metaphorical storms never cease.  He is basically saying that she will be able to keep her innocence well into adulthood, which is an important theme for Yeats.  In the very last stanza, Yeats hopes that his daughter finds a husband who will foster that innocence through ceremony and ritual, which are two more important themes from Yeats’ earlier poetry. 
Yeats, through the use of symbolism and allusion, addresses his own daughter’s maturation, and he dreams of the life he hopes for her to have.  He talks about traits he wishes upon her, such as spiritual beauty and consideration, and the fate of happiness and innocence he hopes for her.  With this poem, he breaks the trend of darkness that can be found in many of his older poems about childhood, and advances towards a theme of optimism.    
Works Cited
           Chang, Tsung-chi. "W. B. Yeats, Cultural Nationalism, and Disempowered Women." Gale. N.p., n.d. Web. 7 Oct. 2013. <http://go.galegroup.com.ccny-    proxy1.libr.ccny.cuny.edu/ps/retrieve.do?sgHitCountType=None&sort=RELEVANCE&            docType=Critical+essay&prodId=GLS&tabID=T001&searchId=R2&resultListType=RE            SULT_LIST&searchType=BasicSearchForm&contentSegment=¤tPosition=2&searchRes            ultsType=MultiTab&inPS=true&userGroupName=cuny_ccny&docId=GALE%7CA3368            44419&contentSet=GALE%7CA336844419>.
           Yeats, W. B. "A Prayer for My Daughter." Michael Robartes and the Dancer. N.p.: Cuala, 1921. N. pag. Poets.org. Academy of American Poets. Web. 07 Oct. 2013.
 

Journal 9


            Both articles provide valid points for and against illegal immigration.  However, I do not know if I can fully agree with either side, as I disagree with some of the points strongly.  For example, Michael Scott writes in his article, “America Must Take Stronger Measures to Halt Illegal Immigration,” about the destruction to personal property and safety hazards that come with the immigrants across the border.  He points to the filth that is left on people’s property as the immigrants move through, and the livestock and pets that are poisoned or have their throats slit by the immigrant guides.  But throughout the article, Scott fails to realize a very critical point; these immigrants are human beings.  They are not simply a plague that pushes itself through the border and into the American economy.  They are people who are, for the most part, looking for a better life that they were promised they would find in the United States.  And in this aspect, Richard Rayner succeeds with his article, “Illegal Immigration Does Not Threaten America.”  He points out the struggles of illegal immigrants who, unlike the popular view point says, are not actually receiving any support from the government, and live their lives in utter poverty in order to get by.  However, neither article provides a real solution to the problem that America sees with illegal immigration. 
            The solution, to me, is quite simple, however.  I think that what needs to be done is the process to become a citizen needs to be simplified.  There need to be stations at critical locations along the border to help immigrants who want to be legal to understand what is needed to become a citizen.  A quick Google search brings up the website that explains the whole process, and at first glance it looks very straightforward.  After a minute, however, I realized that there are a few problems with the system.  The first problem is that immigrants do not have access to this information if they do not have a computer.  Who knows how to apply for citizenship other than on the internet?  Who would be able to give this information out?  How do people find the people who have this information if they are not making themselves known?  The second problem is that, as with all processes that are tied to the government, it is not terribly simple to understand.  Even if somehow the immigrants gained access to a computer, if the website is too hard to understand, it’s as if they didn’t have the resource to begin with. Not every immigrant has someone to ask for help with this, who is on hand whenever they need them.  Even then, after understanding the process, they would find out that they need to fill out forms for a green card, then wait five years before having any hope of becoming a citizen.  But I’m sure many immigrants would have no problem doing this, as long as the information is provided.  As a bonus, this system would provide more jobs for the American people by placing them at the border to help immigrants through properly, and in positions to help them understand the process. 

Journal 8


            The three articles, “Black Friday: Consumerism Minus Civilization” by Andrew Leonard, “Friday’s Deals May Not Be the Best” by Stephanie Clifford, and “For Some Black Friday First-Timers, Not a Night of Conversion” by Stephanie Clifford and Christopher Maag, all address the issues that can be found when looking at Black Friday as a cultural phenomenon.  Each article approaches the topic with different main ideas, but each reaches the same basic conclusion about Black Friday; that the idea of its deals and discounts cause people to act crazily.
            In Leonard’s article, he approaches the topic of Black Friday through the human morality aspect, and focusing mainly on the issue of Black Friday advertising.  He argues that the ideals present in the minds of the shoppers on Black Friday go against what we, as humans, find morally right.  However, he writes, the craziness of the shoppers, like the Crazy Target Lady from Target’s Black Friday commercial, is “a culturally approved lunacy.”  Not only is this characteristic of the event itself, but Leonard says that the individual stores use their advertisements to foster this immoral behavior, the insanity that goes on inside the stores and even before hand as people prepare to go shopping early in the morning or late at night.
            In the first New York Times article by Stephanie Clifford, “Friday’s Deals May Not Be the Best”, Clifford writes that, despite the hype and advertising done by businesses, Black Friday does not even actually help the consumers.  Although the advertisements make it seem like these Black Friday deals are the very best and lowest prices, this, in reality, is not the case.  Black Friday is the day when retailers, historically, see an increase in sales due to the day’s proximity to Christmas.  Because people see this time as the best time to start holiday shopping, retailers react by hosting sales to get people to come to their stores.  However, as Clifford points out, the reality is that if consumers were to wait just a few more weeks, they would find even better sales and discounts because stores need to sell their inventory quickly, or risk never selling it at all. 
            The next article, “For Some Black Friday First-Timers, Not a Night of Conversion” by Stephanie Clifford and Christopher Maag, focuses on the consumer, especially first-time Black Friday shoppers.  The shoppers learn the realities of Black Friday, people being trampled and fighting over products.  Some people don’t even have anything to show for their trip.  The article shows that that year’s Black Friday brought in around two thousand more people to Macy’s Herald Square than the year before.  The article goes on to show why this was the case.  Because people found themselves out of work or with a much decreased income, they figured that their only hope was to brave the crowds on Black Friday in order to catch the much needed sales and discounts. 

Journal 6

            In the poem, “When I Was One-and-Twenty,” by A.E. Housman, the poet addresses the theme of lost, unrequited, or forsaken love.  In the first stanza, the speaker of the poem is approached by a “wise man,” or probably a member of the generation before him, as many young people, and the speaker, realize too late are people to be listened to and their advice is to be heeded.  The wise man warns the speaker that he should be careful when it comes to matters of love.  He is told that the heart is not like money, and that if it is given away prematurely, it will cause the giver pain and sorrow.  Nevertheless, the speaker of the poem, being young and free-spirited, naturally disregards the advice, feeling, as many young people do, that his youth should be spent freely, and that all his assets, his heart included, should be given away generously because he has so much to give. 
            In the second stanza, the speaker of the poem is warned again of the dangers of giving away his love.  The reader can assume, through the fact that this is something everyone is advised on and is rarely obeyed, that he is warned many, many times by different people.  He continues to ignore the warnings, however, and pays the price for his foolishness.  By the end of the poem, the speaker realizes how true the wise man’s words were, and he mourns his lost love.  The speaker then becomes the wise man to all the readers of his poem. 
            The theme of lost love in this poem is very different from that of other poems, like “Anabel Lee,” by Edgar Allan Poe, for example.  In Poe’s poem, the love was not given away, but shared.  It was the actual object of his affection that was lost due to premature death, rather than the action, as in “When I Was One and Twenty,” falling on an unwilling object. 
            With some research, one can find that the “lost love” that Housman talks about in his poem is based off his feelings for his college roommate (Poets.org).  His roommate, predictably, did not return his feelings, which depressed Housman.  Because of his foolish actions, Housman went on to fail his exams, and only just managed to pass his classes.  For the rest of his life, he lived in solitude. 

 

Works Cited
"A. E. Housman." Poets.org. Academy of American Poets, n.d. Web. 15 Oct. 2013.

Journal 5

            In her essay, Berry makes the argument that fashion advertisements have recently begun to allow the consumer to be an “individual,” unlike previous fashion and health and beauty advertisements that seemingly forced the viewer to want to conform to a societal definition of “beautiful.”  Her argument is based on two shoe ads depicting young women in outfits showing their originality.  Although the two women shown in the advertisements show their inarguable uniqueness, Berry’s argument is flawed.  The companies are not showing how the individual can be unique through the individuality of their models, but rather they are showing how their product stands apart from the rest. 
            There is one rather important reason that can be argued for the company, Clarks, to use a “band geek” type of style to promote their product.  This reason that comes to mind requires some knowledge of Clarks’ shoes and what being in a high school or college level band, which the model seemingly is in, entails.  Clarks’ shoes are known for their comfort and support, especially when the wearer has to be on his or her feet for long period of time.  In a marching band, the members are required to be on their feet for what can be hours, especially during practice.  So Clarks’ shoes would be a great choice for a young woman who is in a band and is looking for a pair of shoes that are good for her feet and are attractive as well.  With this approach, it is seen that the ad is not showing how the consumer can be an individual, but rather how those with individual hobbies and passions can continue to do what they love without sacrificing their fashion sense.  This particular advertisement is obviously reaching out to this particular group of consumers. 
            The second ad shows an entirely different aspect of advertising that has next to nothing to do with individuality.  This ad shows the product in a setting that is out of the ordinary and very attention grabbing.  It shows a woman in a very luxurious room and dress, wearing red snow boots.  The boots do not match the rest of the picture, and so that is what the viewers’ eyes are drawn to, effectively catching the attention of potential consumers. 
            A company’s main objective is to get the consumer to buy their product.  Fashion companies will often do this through visual advertisements, which makes sense because a consumer is likely to buy something that is visually appealing to them.  Although a company may use the want of the consumer to conform to society, the company does not, however, necessarily have the need or want to get the consumer to conform to a certain societal norm, and therefore would have no reason to do the opposite and foster individual creativity.  The point of these two advertisements was to either appeal to an ideal that is already present in the minds of the company’s target consumer or to catch the attention of the consumer with an outlandish yet visually appealing image.  Neither of the advertisements actually stray from the standard set by advertisements of showing attractive young women, and therefore are not much different from previous ads that have the same object of their pictures.  These advertisements are not allowing the viewer to be an individual, they are simply doing their jobs as ads.