Annotated Bibliography


Thesis: Stem cells have many potentially useful, and often life-saving, applications, and yet, because of the controversy behind their use, research into them and these applications is not allowed to move forward. 

Carvalho, Ana Sofia, and João Ramalho-Santos. "How Can Ethics Relate To Science? The Case   Of Stem Cell Research." European Journal Of Human Genetics 21.6 (2013): 591-595.          Academic Search Complete. Web. 18 Nov. 2013.

                        This article looks to prove that ethics are needed in scientific research.  The authors point to embryonic stem cell research as an example.  They state that, as of now, ethics and research are separated, as people believe that one cannot exist in the presence of the other.  It is stated that, since the controversies are not in line with a scientific way of thinking, they are unhelpful.  The authors say that ethics combined with science will not hinder research, but rather support it. 

            This article is somewhat reliable.  However, because it is an argumentative essay, the point is to convince the reader to agree with the point of view of the author.  The article does not simply state facts, as in the case of the scientific studies.  Despite the fact that it is an opinionated article, I believe I will still be able to use it when explaining the moral issues surrounding stem cell research.  It would be difficult to find a completely objective article on the subject, and this article approaches the topic in an academic manner.

Drury-Stewart, Danielle, et al. "Highly Efficient Differentiation Of Neural Precursors From          Human Embryonic Stem Cells And Benefits Of Transplantation After Ischemic Stroke In Mice." Stem Cell Research & Therapy 4.4 (2013): 1-13. Academic Search Complete.     Web. 18 Nov. 2013.

                        The authors of this article sought to find a way to use stem cells to treat ischemic strokes.  Ischemic strokes are caused by clots in the arteries in the brain.  Since neural cells do not easily regenerate on their own after trauma, it has been difficult for medical professionals to treat patients who have had strokes.  Ischemic strokes are one of the leading causes of death, and a new treatment would greatly impact a large number of lives.  By using embryonic stem cells, the researchers found a much more accessible treatment for these strokes. 

            This article is reputable, as it is a scientific study and therefore based on facts and not opinions.  As the authors of this article are the ones who conducted the research, this article would be a primary source.  The article is unbiased, furthering its reliability.  This study will help support my thesis, as it shows an example of how stem cell research benefits the medical community.  Because it is a reliable source, it will help keep my essay credible. 

Mong-Lien, Wang, Chiou Shih-Hwa, and Wu Cheng-Wen. "Targeting Cancer Stem Cells:            Emerging Role Of Nanog Transcription Factor." Oncotargets & Therapy 6.(2013): 1207-       1220. Academic Search Complete. Web. 18 Nov. 2013.

                        This article focuses on the possibility of cancer treatment with stem cell research.  The authors explain that research has shown that it is possible to reprogram cancer cells back to embryonic stem cell like status.  This would completely eradicate the cancer from the cells.  This is unlike other cancer treatments, which sometimes cannot completely remove the cancerous cells.  The authors explain that more research is needed, however, to optimize this treatment. 

            Like the previous article, this article is a scientific study.  It is also a primary source, as the researchers wrote the article themselves.  The article is based on facts rather than opinions, and is therefore a reliable source.  I will use this article to help support my argument that stem cell research can help find treatments for cancer, and therefore benefit the community.  The reliability of the article will add credibility to my essay.

Post, Mark J. "Cultured Meat From Stem Cells: Challenges And Prospects." Meat Science 92.3    (2012): 297-301. Academic Search Complete. Web. 18 Nov. 2013.

            The author of this article argues that more research should be done on creating food products directly from stem cells.  He states that researchers have already been able to create animal tissue from stem cells.  By furthering the research done in this area, he argues that food production from stem cells is not an impossibility.  Furthermore, he states that not only can it be done, but it should be.  The author says that this will help the meat industry, as well as finding healthier meat products. 

            This article is mostly reliable.  It is based mostly on facts, however it is not completely unbiased.  It is an argumentative article, so the authors own opinions are prevalent.  It is also not a primary source, since there is no single study that is being referenced.  Despite its somewhat biased nature, I can still use the facts stated in the article to support the idea that stem cell research in the area of food production would greatly benefit society. 

No comments:

Post a Comment