Journal 3


            In her essay, Amy Tan writes about how the lives of her and her mother were affected by their English language skills.  She describes how, because of her mother’s “broken” English, people treated her poorly.  She talks about how her mother’s stockbroker tried to cheat her mother because her command of the English language made him think of her as less intelligent.  She talks about how the hospital, a place full of people who are meant to do their best to help people, lost a very important CAT scan, and instead of apologizing and trying to find it as quickly as possible, they wanted to force her mother to make a whole new appointment.  She also says how Tan would be forced to speak on behalf of her mother so that people would here the more proper English and respect her more.  This is a significant topic for her because it addresses the catalyst, so to speak, that set her on the path to become what she is now.  This catalyst being the embarrassment and anger that Tan felt when put in situations such as these. 

            Tan’s essay is about the different types of English that she has used throughout her life.  And although she only talks about herself and her mother, this idea applies to every speaker of any language.  We all use different wording when talking to different audiences, and Tan’s and her mother’s “broken” English is simply a type of very informal speech.  The main point is that anyone can succeed in the English language, even if you start even at the most basic levels, like Tan did. 

            Along with the embarrassment and anger Tan sensed when people disrespected her mother because of her “broken” English, she felt driven to prove her mastery over English because of her experience in her education.  Because she did not grow up in a house where perfect English was spoken, Tan’s scores in the subject were not as high as they could have been, especially when compared to her math grades.  So, instead of pushing her to succeed in English, her teachers fostered her math and science skills.  This caused Tan to want to prove herself.  She didn’t want to be like so many other Asian-Americans succeeding only in math and science fields.  So she became an English major.  Her drive to succeed made her different from her peers.  Instead of following the path others set for her, Tan worked hard and set herself on a new one. 

            Amy Tan could have easily followed any number of math or science related paths.  She could have had no drive whatsoever to rebel against those teachers and bosses who stood between her and her success as a writer or even as an English speaker.  But she didn’t follow those paths, and she did rebel.  And in the process, she became a writer who could show the different types of English that every speaker of the language uses, from the most formal and proper to the same “broken” English as her mother. 

No comments:

Post a Comment